Mazda vs. Honda Reliability: Which Brand Truly Lasts?

When it comes to choosing a reliable car, both Mazda and Honda stand out as top contenders. Known for their engineering excellence and durability, these brands have earned loyal followings worldwide. But if you’re torn between Mazda and Honda, this guide thoroughly explores Mazda’s vs. Honda’s reliability and compares build quality, maintenance costs, and long-term dependability to determine which brand truly lasts.

Brief Overview of Mazda and Honda as Automotive Manufacturers

Mazda and Honda are two of the most reputable automotive manufacturers, each with decades of innovation and a commitment to quality. With Japanese roots, both brands consistently rank highly in reliability studies and consumer satisfaction reports, making them favorites among practical and performance-focused drivers alike.

Importance of Reliability in Choosing a Vehicle

Reliability is a critical factor when purchasing a car. A dependable vehicle not only minimizes unexpected repairs but also reduces ownership costs over time. With the average cost of car repairs rising by nearly 25% between the beginning of 2022 and June 2024, selecting a reliable brand is more important than ever. 

Besides reduced ownership costs, vehicles with reliable reputations also command a higher resale value. When it’s time to sell, you’re likely going to receive a higher return on your investment compared to less reliable vehicles.

Historical Reliability Overview: Mazda vs. Honda

Drivers consistently praise Mazda’s engineering prowess and simplicity. In 2020, Mazda topped Consumer Reports’ reliability rankings, outranking even Toyota, which is often considered the gold standard for reliability. In subsequent years, Mazda has remained near the top, with models such as the Mazda CX-5 and Mazda MX-5 Miata earning accolades for their dependability.

Honda has a long-standing reputation for creating lasting vehicles. Iconic models such as the Honda Accord and Honda Civic have been mainstays in reliability rankings for decades. While Honda has slightly dipped in recent rankings, it should remain a go-to brand if you’re seeking longevity and low maintenance costs.

In the latest Consumer Reports reliability rankings, Mazda ranked fourth, while Honda followed closely at fifth.

Analyzing Current Models

Mazda’s 2024 lineup balances performance and reliability. The CX-30 and CX-5 received praise for their smooth ride, efficient engines, and robust safety features. The iconic Mazda 3 combines sporty handling with exceptional reliability, while the Mazda MX-5 Miata remains a reliable sports car favorite.

Honda continues to offer versatile and dependable options such as the Honda Civic, which consistently delivers reliable and fuel-efficient performance, making it a favorite among commuters. The Honda CR-V maintains its position as a practical, family-friendly SUV with a strong reliability track record. In the Honda Accord, you get a popular midsize sedan known for its longevity and practicality. The Honda Pilot is also a reliable people hauler, even though the Mazda CX-90 beats it in almost all metrics. 

Reliability Comparison

According to Consumer Reports’ statistics, Mazda and Honda both excel in reliability, but Mazda edges out in some categories. Mazda’s overall reliability score is 65 points, while Honda scores 62 points. Meanwhile, J.D. Power, another reputable rating agency, rates Honda higher than Mazda in terms of reliability.

Key Factors Influencing Reliability Scores

There are several factors that determine reliability scores. 

Build Quality and Engineering Practices

Mazda’s Skyactiv technology is a standout feature, emphasizing fuel efficiency and durability without compromising performance, whereas Honda is known for its robust engines and simple yet effective designs, which contribute to its long-term dependability. There’s no clear winner here — both brands focus on engineering excellence, so you can’t go wrong with either of them.

Customer Feedback and Recalls History

Mazda has fewer recalls on average compared to Honda. Additionally, Mazda owners report high satisfaction with the brand’s performance and reliability over time. While Honda remains a trusted name, recent recalls in some models have slightly impacted its perception.

Warranty Offers and Servicing Packages

Both brands offer the same competitive warranties, including a three-year/36,000-mile limited warranty. However, Mazda tops this with a lifetime limited warranty for brake components and more robust dealership support. This can make a big difference in the long-term ownership experience.

Maintenance Costs

In terms of ownership costs, both Mazda and Honda are affordable compared to luxury brands. However, Honda has a slight edge in repair costs:

• Mazda average repair cost: $896 per visit
• Honda average repair cost: $815 per visit

While Mazda parts are cheaper, owners may require additional parts per visit compared to Honda, slightly increasing overall costs.

Safety Features That Enhance Longevity

Safety features not only protect passengers but also ensure the vehicle’s longevity by preventing accidents. Mazda outshines Honda in safety awards:

• Every 2023 Mazda model earned an Insurance Institute for Highway Safety Top Safety Pick+ award.
• Only two Honda models earned the same distinction.

Mazda’s advanced safety features, such as smart brake support and lane-keep assist, contribute to its reliability by reducing wear and tear and avoiding collisions.

Resale Value: Mazda vs. Honda

Both Mazda and Honda retain their value well over time, but Honda has traditionally had a slight edge in resale value due to its widespread recognition as a dependable brand. However, Mazda’s growing reputation for reliability is closing the gap.

Making an Informed Decision

Choosing between Mazda and Honda ultimately depends on your priorities. If you value cutting-edge safety features, exceptional reliability scores, and dealership support, Mazda may be the better choice. If you’re looking for a brand with proven longevity, lower repair costs, and better resale value, Honda offers a compelling option.

Mazda’s recent strides in reliability and engineering make it a solid contender against Honda’s established reputation. If you want a dependable, well-rounded vehicle, either brand is a smart investment.

Schedule a Test-Drive Today at Mazda of Conshohocken

Are you ready to experience Mazda’s prowess in automotive innovation? Explore the latest lineup to see why it’s gaining traction as a reliability leader. Visit Mazda of Conshohocken or contact us online to schedule your test-drive. We’ll help you find the perfect vehicle to match your needs.

Posted in Brand vs. Brand | No Comments »